Minor Deficiencies In Grounds Communicated To UAPA Accused Don't Invalidate Arrest Unless Prejudice Is Shown: J&K&L High Court

  • Minor Deficiencies In Grounds Communicated To UAPA Accused Dont Invalidate Arrest Unless Prejudice Is Shown: J&K&L High Court

    The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has held that even if grounds of arrest are deficient in details about the allegations against UAPA accused, as long as grounds are communicated in writing and explained in a language accused understands, it amounts to substantial compliance of Article 22(1) of the Constitution.Finding no demonstrable prejudice to two men accused of allegedly...

    The Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has held that even if grounds of arrest are deficient in details about the allegations against UAPA accused, as long as grounds are communicated in writing and explained in a language accused understands, it amounts to substantial compliance of Article 22(1) of the Constitution.

    Finding no demonstrable prejudice to two men accused of allegedly providing shelter and logistical support to terrorists, the Court refused to grant them bail in a case involving offences under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA).

    A Division Bench comprising Justice Sanjay Dhar and Justice Shahzad Azeem dismissed appeals filed by Ashiq Ali alias Akhi and Lal Hussain against the rejection of their bail applications by the designated TADA/POTA Court in Jammu. The appellants had contended that their arrest and subsequent remand were illegal because the grounds of arrest had not been properly communicated to them.

    "In the present case, as already stated, the allegations in brief against the appellants were conveyed to them in writing and the same were explained to them in the language they understood. Therefore, even if the grounds of arrest are deficient in details about the allegations against the appellants, it can still be safely stated that there has been substantial compliance to the mandate of Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 50 of Cr. P. C, corresponding to Section 47 of BNSS, in the present case".

    Relying upon the Supreme Court's decision in State of Meghalaya v. Sonam Raghuvanshi, the Court noted the distinction between non-service of grounds of arrest and non-furnishing of adequate reasons in the document. While the former may vitiate the arrest, the latter requires an assessment of the prejudice caused to the accused.

    The Bench also referred to State of Karnataka v. Sri Darshan and Others, observing that no specific form has been prescribed for communicating the grounds of arrest and that substantial compliance with the constitutional and statutory requirements would suffice in the absence of demonstrable prejudice.

    The Bench held that there is a distinction between non-service of grounds of arrest and a grievance that the grounds furnished were not sufficiently detailed. While non-service may vitiate an arrest, an allegation of inadequacy requires examination of the prejudice caused to the accused.

    “The grounds of arrest in the instant case give a gist of the activities in which the appellants have indulged, which prompted the investigating agency to effect their arrest,” the Court observed.

    Background

    The appeals arose from FIR registered at Police Station Hiranagar for offences under Sections 13, 16, 18 and 23 of the UAPA, Sections 302, 307, 120-B, 121, 121-A and 122 of the Indian Penal Code, Sections 4 and 5 of the Explosive Substances Act and Section 7/27 of the Arms Act.

    According to the prosecution, the police received information that armed terrorists had illegally crossed the International Border and entered Village Saida Sohal in Tehsil Hiranagar, where they opened indiscriminate fire upon civilians, injuring one Omkar Sharma.

    When security forces cordoned off the area, the terrorists allegedly fired at the search parties and hurled hand grenades. In the ensuing encounter, two unidentified terrorists were killed, while another managed to escape. A CRPF constable sustained injuries and subsequently succumbed to them. 

    During the investigation, it allegedly emerged that Ashiq Ali and co-accused Ashraf Ali, along with other persons involved in bovine smuggling, had come into contact with three armed terrorists during the intervening night of June 7 and 8, 2024.

    The charge sheet also alleged that the terrorists were associated with Jaish-e-Mohammed and had killed Basudev, a cook working at a construction company in 2024, before meeting the appellants.

    Following completion of the investigation, a charge sheet was filed against the appellants, Ashraf Ali and the killed and escaped terrorists, including Jaish-e-Mohammed chief Maulana Masood Azhar. The designated trial court framed charges against the appellants on February 6, 2025. As many as 83 prosecution witnesses were cited, of whom five had been examined when the High Court considered the appeals.

    Court's Observation

    The Bench examined the constitutional requirement under Article 22(1) of the Constitution, which mandates that an arrested person must be informed of the grounds of arrest, and considered the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Mihir Rajesh Shah.

    Referring to the Supreme Court's formulation, the High Court noted that the grounds of arrest must ordinarily be communicated in writing in a language understood by the arrestee. Where immediate written communication is not possible, the grounds may initially be communicated orally, but must subsequently be furnished in writing within a reasonable time and, in any event, at least two hours before production for remand.

    The Bench then turned to the distinction between the expression “reasons for arrest” and “grounds of arrest”, as explained by the Supreme Court in Prabir Purkayastha.

    It observed that reasons for arrest refer to formal considerations such as preventing further offences, ensuring proper investigation, preventing destruction of evidence or avoiding threats or inducements to witnesses. In contrast, the grounds of arrest must contain the basic facts in the investigating officer's possession which necessitated the arrest.

    The Court observed,

    “The grounds of arrest informed in writing must convey to the arrested accused all basic facts on which he was being arrested so as to provide him an opportunity of defending himself against custodial remand and to seek bail.”

    Examining the trial court record, the Bench found that the appellants had been furnished written grounds of arrest in English. The document recorded that they had allegedly met armed terrorists and arranged shelter, logistics, food and water for them during the intervening night of June 7 and 8, 2024.

    It also recorded that the grounds had been read over to the appellants in the language they fully understood, following which they had affixed their signatures or thumb impressions.

    The appellants argued that the contents of the document amounted merely to reasons for arrest and did not constitute the actual grounds of arrest.

    Rejecting this contention, the Bench held that the document communicated the gist of the activities allegedly undertaken by the appellants, which had prompted the investigating agency to arrest them. It noted that the document did not merely refer to formal considerations such as preventing further offences, tampering with evidence or threatening witnesses.

    The Court accordingly observed,

    “This gist of facts contained in the writing communicated to the appellants falls within the category of 'grounds of arrest' as explained by the Supreme Court in Prabir Purkayastha's case.”

    It added that there was no reason, at that stage, to disbelieve the record showing that the grounds of arrest had been explained to the appellants in a language they understood. However, the appellants would remain at liberty to cross-examine the arresting officer on this aspect during the trial.

    The Bench also considered whether any deficiency in the detail of the grounds of arrest would automatically render the arrest and subsequent remand illegal.

    It noted, “Article 22(1) is satisfied if the accused is made aware of arrest grounds in substance, even if not conveyed in writing.”

    Applying these principles, the Court found that the allegations against the appellants had been communicated to them in writing and explained in a language they understood. It therefore concluded that there had been substantial compliance with Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 47 of the BNSS.

    The appeals were dismissed. 

    Next Story