Inordinate Delay Of Six Years In Deciding Objections Shocks Conscience Of Court: J&K&L High Court Seeks Report From Magistrate

  • Inordinate Delay Of Six Years In Deciding Objections Shocks Conscience Of Court: J&K&L High Court Seeks Report From Magistrate
    Listen to this Article

    The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh at Jammu, observing that it shocks the conscience of the Court that the Executing Court failed to decide objections for six years, has directed the Registry to obtain a report from the learned Additional Special Mobile Magistrate, Samba, explaining the reasons for the inordinate delay.

    The Court held that the failure to decide the objections, particularly when a specific preliminary objection regarding limitation was raised, warranted intervention under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

    The Court was hearing a petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India by the decree holders/petitioners seeking a direction to the trial court to decide their objections expeditiously. The objections were filed against an application moved by the respondents seeking setting aside of an ex parte decree, which had been stayed by the Executing Court without affording the petitioners an opportunity of being heard.

    The matter was heard by Justice Wasim Sadiq Nargal, who observed,

    “It shocks the conscience of this Court that the learned Executing Court has failed to decide the objections raised by the petitioners to the application seeking setting aside of the decree, particularly when a specific preliminary objection regarding limitation has also been raised therein, and the matter has remained pending for the last six years.

    Background

    A decree was passed by the trial Court in favour of the petitioners on 30.08.2018'. Thereafter, the petitioners preferred an execution application on 17.01.2019, in which notice was issued. Subsequently, the respondents preferred an application seeking setting aside of the decree dated 30.08.2018.

    The petitioners submitted that without affording them an opportunity of being heard, the Executing Court, vide order dated 17.05.2019, stayed the execution of the aforesaid decree. The petitioners further submitted that they filed detailed objections challenging the maintainability of the application seeking stay of execution of the decree, inter alia, on the ground that the said application was filed beyond the period of limitation.

    However, the said objections had not been decided till date, and the interim order passed by the learned Executing Court staying the execution of the ex parte decree continued to remain in operation, causing serious prejudice to the petitioners.

    Aggrieved by the inaction on the part of the competent Court in deciding the said objections, the petitioners preferred the instant petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, seeking a direction to the learned Trial Court to decide the same expeditiously.

    Court's Observation

    The Court observed that it was very strange that the objections, which as per the petitioners were filed way back on 05.05.2020, had not been decided by the Court of learned Additional Special Mobile Magistrate, Samba, even after a lapse of six years, which prompted the petitioners to approach the Court by way of the instant petition.

    The Court held,

    “It is very strange that the objections, which as per petitioners, were filed way back on 05.05.2020, till date, have not been decided by the Court of learned Additional Special Mobile Magistrate, Samba, even after a lapse of six years, which prompted the petitioners to approach this Court by way of the instant petition.”

    The Court further held,

    “It shocks the conscience of this Court that the learned Executing Court has failed to decide the objections raised by the petitioners to the application seeking setting aside of the decree, particularly when a specific preliminary objection regarding limitation has also been raised therein, and the matter has remained pending for the last six years.”

    The Court, accordingly, in light of the submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioners and in light of the contemporaneous official record, before proceeding further in the matter, deemed it appropriate to direct the Registry to obtain a report from the learned Additional Special Mobile Magistrate, Samba, in the case titled 'Krishna Devi & Ors. Vs. Oma Chouhan & Ors.', within a period of one week positively, explaining the reasons for the inordinate delay in deciding the objections filed by the petitioners.

    The Court held,

    “Accordingly, in light of submissions made by learned counsel for the petitioners and in light of contemporaneous official record, this Court before proceeding further in the matter, deems it appropriate to direct the Registry to obtain a report from the learned Additional Special Mobile Magistrate, Samba, in the case titled 'Krishna Devi & Ors. Vs. Oma Chouhan & Ors.', within a period of one week positively, explaining the reasons for the inordinate delay in deciding the objections filed by the petitioners.”

    The matter was directed to be listed in continuation on 18.11.2026.

    Appearances

    Petitioners: Senior Advocate Aseem Kumar Sawhney with Advocates Dheeraj Singh, Tehseena Bukhari, and Mohd. Shabab Malik


    Case Title :  Romesh Singh & Anr. v. Oma Chauhan & Anr.
    Next Story