Photographs Of Couple Together Or Family Outings Can't Disprove Allegations Of Matrimonial Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court

  • Photographs Of Couple Together Or Family Outings Cant Disprove Allegations Of Matrimonial Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court

    The Jharkhand High Court has held that occasional visits to religious places, participation in family functions or photographs taken during celebrations cannot automatically neutralise the effect of other acts of cruelty in a matrimonial relationship. The Court observed that a marriage may appear outwardly cordial on certain occasions even while one spouse experiences humiliation, harassment...

    The Jharkhand High Court has held that occasional visits to religious places, participation in family functions or photographs taken during celebrations cannot automatically neutralise the effect of other acts of cruelty in a matrimonial relationship.  

    The Court observed that a marriage may appear outwardly cordial on certain occasions even while one spouse experiences humiliation, harassment and mental suffering during ordinary matrimonial life.

    A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Akhil Kumar set aside a Family Court judgment dismissing a wife's divorce petition, holding that the existence of occasional cordial moments in a marriage cannot outweigh other evidence of cruelty without examining the matrimonial relationship in its entirety.

    "A matrimonial relationship may remain outwardly cordial on certain occasions and yet one spouse may be subjected to humiliation, harassment and mental agony during the course of ordinary matrimonial life. Occasional visits to religious places, participation in family functions or photographs taken during celebrations cannot automatically neutralise the effect of other acts of cruelty".

    The case arose from a divorce petition filed by the wife against her husband under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, on the grounds of cruelty and desertion.

    According to the wife, her husband had subjected her to physical and mental harassment, repeatedly insulted her and her family members, and used abusive language against them. She further alleged that her husband had demanded cash and a vehicle, taken away her ornaments and repeatedly threatened to divorce her. She claimed that she was eventually compelled to reside at her parental home.

    The husband denied the allegations and contested the divorce petition. On April 30, 2026, the Family Court dismissed the wife's petition. Aggrieved, she approached the High Court.

    Examining the evidence, the High Court noted that the wife had testified about the alleged demands for cash and a vehicle, physical and mental harassment, and the circumstances compelling her to leave the matrimonial home. Her testimony was also supported by the depositions of her maternal uncle and mother. The Court noted that certain circumstances had emerged during cross-examination, including that the parties had initially married by choice, their families had subsequently participated in a social marriage ceremony, and the couple had undertaken religious and recreational journeys together.

    However, the Bench held that such circumstances could not conclusively establish that the husband had never subjected his wife to cruelty. 

    The Bench further noted that the husband had relied heavily on the couple's visits to Vaishno Devi, Ujjain and other places. However, during cross-examination, he admitted that he had not produced travel tickets or other documentary material establishing the details of these visits. The Court found that the Family Court had attached considerable importance to the couple's participation in social and religious functions without adequately examining the wife's allegations of sustained matrimonial harassment. It held that matrimonial cruelty must be assessed through the cumulative effect of the parties' conduct and the entire course of their relationship.

    Emphasising that outward appearances of matrimonial harmony cannot automatically disprove cruelty, the Court further observed:

    “It is well settled that the existence of some cordial moments in a matrimonial relationship does not necessarily exclude the possibility of cruelty. A marriage is required to be assessed in its entirety, and the Court cannot disregard the suffering of one spouse merely because the parties were seen together on certain occasions.”

    The Bench also reiterated that the standard of proof in matrimonial proceedings is the preponderance of probabilities, rather than proof beyond reasonable doubt.

    Upon examining the wife's testimony along with the supporting evidence of other witnesses, the Court concluded that the husband's conduct had caused serious matrimonial discord and mental suffering. It further held that the husband's subsequent willingness to maintain the wife or resume cohabitation could not erase the effect of his earlier conduct.

    The Court observed that a wife cannot be compelled to resume cohabitation merely because her husband expresses willingness to take her back. The circumstances surrounding her withdrawal from the matrimonial home must first be examined.

    The Bench ultimately held that the wife had successfully established matrimonial cruelty under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, and that she had been compelled to leave the matrimonial home for reasonable cause.

    Accordingly, the High Court set aside the Family Court's judgment dated April 30, 2026, and decree dated May 7, 2026, rejecting the wife's petition for dissolution of marriage.

    Appearance:

    For the Appellant: Mr. Amit Kumar Chaturvedi, Advocate

    For the Respondent: Mr. Arbind Kumar, Advocate; Mr. Prem Prakash, Advocate; Ms. Sakshi Diksha, Advocate

    Next Story