Police Can't Implicate Jewellers In Gold Theft Cases Solely On Co-Accused's Confession: Karnataka High Court

  • Police Cant Implicate Jewellers In Gold Theft Cases Solely On Co-Accuseds Confession: Karnataka High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Karnataka High Court quashed the criminal proceedings against two jewellers accused of gold theft and house trespass, observing that the two were implicated solely on the basis of the allegations made by two other accused which were neither independently verified nor corroborated by the police.

    The court also directed the DGP to submit SOP on investigation of theft cases especially cases of gold theft from residences, adding that the procedure must ensure that the allegations made by an accused person against another are independently verified and reasonable efforts are made to collect corroborative evidence.

    Justice Suraj Govindaraj was hearing two criminal petitions filed by the two jewellers, who were arrayed as the fourth and fifth accused in two separate theft cases. They allegedly purchased the stolen articles from two persons— arrayed as the first and second accused— who were alleged to have committed the thefts.

    Commenting on the failure of the police to independently verify the allegations made against the petitioners by the alleged perpetrators, the Court said,

    “The investigating officer is expected not merely to apprehend the alleged perpetrators and record their statements, but also to independently verify the allegations made by them, trace the stolen property, ascertain its subsequent movement and collect material capable of corroborating the alleged involvement of other accused persons.”

    It further said, “In the present cases, the material placed before this Court indicates that the investigation, insofar as the petitioners are concerned, has substantially rested upon the statements of accused Nos.1 and 2, without any apparent effort to independently verify or corroborate the allegation that the stolen gold articles had been sold to accused Nos.4 and 5.”

    The Court noted that, in the first case, the stolen articles were recovered from the house of the first and second accused, contradicting their claim that the valuables had been sold to the petitioner-jewellers.

    “The recovery so effected does not lend support to the allegation that the stolen articles had been sold to accused Nos.4 and 5. On the contrary, the recovery from the house of accused No.1 casts serious doubt on the allegation made in the confession statement regarding the alleged sale of the articles to the petitioners. The prosecution has not placed any independent material on record to corroborate the said allegation,” the Court said.

    In the second case, the articles were neither recovered nor any material corroborating the alleged sale to the petitioners was found, the Court observed.

    Accordingly, the Court held, “The material on record, therefore, does not disclose a sufficient basis to proceed against the petitioners or indicate a reasonable prospect of their conviction.”

    The High Court allowed the criminal petitions and quashed the criminal proceedings initiated against the petitioner in both cases.

    It further directed the Director General of Police and Inspector General of Police to place on record the standard operating procedure issued by him to the concerned Investigating Officer in respect of house theft, more particularly theft of gold.

    "Such procedure shall ensure that the allegations made by an accused person against another are subjected to independent verification and that reasonable efforts are made to trace and recover the stolen property and collect corroborative evidence," the court directed.

    Case Title :  VINOD KUMAR & ANOTHER v/s STATE OF KARNATAKA & ANOTHERCase Number :  CRL.P No. 1035/2025
    Next Story