62 RTI Applications In Two Months? Karnataka High Court Flags Misuse Of Law To Harass Officials, Quashes Penalty On Information Officer

  • 62 RTI Applications In Two Months? Karnataka High Court Flags Misuse Of Law To Harass Officials, Quashes Penalty On Information Officer

    The Karnataka High Court expressed concern over misuse of the Right to Information (RTI) nowadays to harass Public Information Officers (PIOs) for extraneous reasons. The Court made the remark while setting aside the Rs. 25,000 penalty imposed on a PIO for an alleged “inordinate delay” in furnishing information.Justice T.P. Vivekananda further noted that the filing 62 RTI applications in...

    The Karnataka High Court expressed concern over misuse of the Right to Information (RTI) nowadays to harass Public Information Officers (PIOs) for extraneous reasons.

    The Court made the remark while setting aside the Rs. 25,000 penalty imposed on a PIO for an alleged “inordinate delay” in furnishing information.

    Justice T.P. Vivekananda further noted that the filing 62 RTI applications in a short span of two months showed a lack of bona fide intent on the part of the RTI applicant (a Union leader at MSIL), and amounted to misuse of the legislation, while allowing the writ petition filed by the PIO and General Manager of MSIL. The petitioner had challenged an order of the Karnataka Information Commission imposing the penalty on him.

    Observing that the Commission had failed to consider the petitioner's reply to the show-cause notice in its proper perspective, the Court noted that the Union leader had flooded the authority with 62 RTI applications, of which a substantial number of applications had already been processed and answered.

    Further, the information sought in the application that formed the subject matter of the present petition, concerning the post of Director (Marketing) in 2021-2022, did not even pertain to the services of the applicant, the Court stated.

    Commenting on the conduct of the applicant, the Court said, “By looking to the conduct of respondent No.1 in filing 62 applications within a span of about 2 months, a reasonable inference could be drawn that there is no bonafides in the conduct of respondent No.1 in filing the application after the application by misusing the provision of the RTI Act.”

    It added, “The object of enactment of RTI Act is for obtaining information from the public authority for valid and genuine purpose. But now-a-days, it is seen the RTI Act is being used to harass the Public Information Officers for extraneous reasons with oblige [sic] motive.”

    Finding no gross negligence or inordinate delay on the petitioner's part, the Court held that it was “a fit case to set aside the order of imposition of penalty” against him.

    Accordingly, the High Court allowed the writ petition and set aside the penalty of Rs 25,000 imposed on the petitioner.

    Background

    The dispute originated from an RTI application filed by Anjanamurthy A on May 26, 2022, seeking copies of government approval for creating the Director (Marketing) post in MSIL during 2021–2022, along with the promotion order issued by the Managing Director in April 2022–2023.

    As the records were not within the hands of the PIO (the petitioner), he requested the concerned authority to provide him the information. The petitioner received the information on July 26, 2022, which he then forwarded to the applicant on July 28, 2022.

    Dissatisfied with the response, the applicant approached the First Appellate Authority, which rejected his appeal. He subsequently filed a second appeal before the Commission under Section 19(3) of the RTI Act. The Commission issued a show-cause notice and eventually imposed a Rs 25,000 penalty on the PIO on December 6, 2023, citing a 240-day delay in furnishing the information.

    Aggrieved by this, the PIO approached the High Court. He contended that the information had already been furnished on July 28, 2022, leaving no room for an inordinate delay. He further submitted that the applicant had filed 62 RTI applications between April 25, 2022, and August 29, 2022, and that the Commission had completely ignored the detailed explanation provided in the petitioner's October 18, 2023 reply to the show-cause notice.

    Next Story