Trial Judge Can't Gather Additional Evidence During Local Inspection Under Section 347 BNSS: Kerala High Court

  • Trial Judge Cant Gather Additional Evidence During Local Inspection Under Section 347 BNSS: Kerala High Court

    The Kerala High Court recently clarified that a trial judge, while conducting inspection as per Section 347 of the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) cannot venture to gather additional information or evidence. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 627]Justice P.V. Balakrishnan delivered the verdict while considering a plea preferred by one of the accused in an NDPS case.The petitioner is accused of...

    The Kerala High Court recently clarified that a trial judge, while conducting inspection as per Section 347 of the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) cannot venture to gather additional information or evidence. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 627]

    Justice P.V. Balakrishnan delivered the verdict while considering a plea preferred by one of the accused in an NDPS case.

    The petitioner is accused of the offences under Sections 20(b)(ii)(B), 25 and 29 of the NDPS Act. The prosecution allegation is that the 1st accused and the petitioner were found in possession and transporting 11.1 kg of dried ganja kept in a plastic sack beneath the front passenger seat of a Maruti Alto car.

    The petitioner contended before the trial court that there is no sufficient space beneath the seat to conceal the contraband. Since the prosecution did not adduce any evidence regarding the storage space beneath the seat, the petitioner preferred an application before the trial court as per Section 347 BNSS seeking local inspection of the vehicle.

    In the Memorandum of Inspection, the trial judge recorded that there is sufficient space beneah the seat to conceal the contraband. However, since the same did not record the relevant facts for which the inspection was ordered, the petition preferred a petition praying for the preparation of a detailed Memorandum recording the measurement of the space beneath the front passenger seat. The trial court dismissed the plea. Aggrieved, he approached the High Court.

    The petitioner argued that the dismissal of his petition for detailed Memorandum has caused him considerable prejudice since there is no opportunity to cross-examine regarding the recordings in the prepared Memorandum. He added that he was constrained to request for local inspection because the prosecution did not adduce any evidence regarding the storage space underneath the seat.

    The prosecution opposed the plea and submitted that when the petitioner has sought for collection of more details regarding the space beneath the seat, he cannot now turn around to challenge the prior Memorandum.

    After hearing the parties, the Court referred to Section 347 BNSS as well as the High Court decision in State of Kerala v. Chandran and others [1973 KHC 144]. It also referred placed reliance on two Apex Court decisions in Pritam Singh and another v. State of Punjab [(1955) 2 SCC 446] and Keisam Kumar Singh and another v. State of Manipur [(1985) 3 SCC 676] wherein it was held that local inspection must not take the place of evidence since it cannot be tested by cross-examination.

    The Court was of the view that the trial court had ventured to gather additional information/evidence while conducting the local inspection. It added:

    “The observation thus made by the learned Special Judge…is clearly on the disputed question of fact raised in the case i.e., whether the contraband allegedly seized by the prosecution can be kept beneath the passenger seat of the vehicle. If so, I have no hesitation to find that the said observation in…Memorandum is illegal. Consequently, it can be held that…application filed by the petitioner seeking the learned Special Judge to record the dimensions of the space beneath the seat and include it in the Memorandum also has no legs to stand, since it amounts to collection of evidence, which is impermissible.”

    The Court refused to interfere with the order dismissing the petitioner's plea to record additional details in the Memorandum of Inspection. Thus, it dismissed the plea.

    Counsel for the petitioner: S.Rajeev, M.S.Aneer, Anilkumar C.R., Sarath K.P., K.S.Kiran Krishnan, Dipa V., Akash Cherian Thomas, T.P.Aravind, Akshara S., Nivedita Rajeev, Ebee Antony

    Counsel for the respondent: Devadas H. Mallan - Public Prosecutor

    K. Salma Jennath

    Salma Jennath is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering Kerala High Court

    Next Story