Disciplinary Punishment Can't Be Based Solely On Inquiry Report Without Examining Witnesses: Kerala High Court

  • Disciplinary Punishment Cant Be Based Solely On Inquiry Report Without Examining Witnesses: Kerala High Court
    Listen to this Article

    The Kerala High Court has held that disciplinary proceedings cannot be sustained when the findings against an employee are based entirely on an inquiry officer's report without summoning or examining the witnesses whose statements form the basis of the allegations. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 635]

    A Division Bench comprising Justice Devan Ramachandran and Justice Basant Balaji was considering an Original Petition filed by the Union of India and postal authorities against the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Ernakulam Bench, which had set aside disciplinary action against a postal employee accused of submitting an incorrect Transfer Allowance (TA) bill.

    The dispute arose after the respondent in the present case, who is a postal employee working as an LSG Supervisor submitted a bill claiming Transfer Allowance.

    The postal authorities suspected that the claim was false and conducted an inquiry through an Inspector of Posts (IP).

    According to the Inspector's report, he had visited the address where the respondent was stated to have resided and obtained a statement from a person named Shibu. The latter allegedly informed the Inspector that the respondent was his relative and had stayed at that address from March 2020 to October 2020.

    Disciplinary action was initiated based on this report against the respondent for allegedly submitting an incorrect TA bill.

    The respondent, on the other hand, produced documents in support of her claim, including a letter from the owner of the house confirming that she had resided there as a tenant.

    The disciplinary authorities, however, did not accept the respondent's defence and proceeded to impose punishment, relying on the Inspector's report.

    Aggrieved by this, the respondent approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench, which allowed her Original Application by an order dated December 15, 2025. The Union of India and postal authorities challenged that decision before the High Court.

    The High Court identified two significant infirmities in the disciplinary proceedings.

    First, the entire disciplinary action had proceeded on the basis of the Inspector of Posts' report, without summoning or citing any witness, including Shibu, whose statement formed the basis of the allegation.

    The employee had merely been permitted to verify the Inspector's report at the office of the fourth petitioner and submit a reply in defence, disputing its contents.

    The High Court agreed with the Tribunal that an inquiry under Rule 16(1) of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, ought to have been initiated at that stage.

    The second deficiency concerned the unequal treatment of the evidence produced by the employee and the material relied upon by the authorities.

    The respondent - employee had produced a letter from the owner of the house, confirming that she had resided there as a tenant. The authorities disregarded the document on the ground that it had been produced only at the appellate stage.

    However, they had placed complete reliance on the statement allegedly given by Shibu, who was stated to be an NRI and was not ordinarily available in India. The authorities had also not cogently established his relationship with the house owner.

    "It is rather pertinent that a certificate issued by the owner of the house has been completely discarded; while, the statement of a person stated to be an NRI - who is not ordinarily available in India and whose relationship with the owner has not even been cogently established - has been wholly relied upon by the Authorities." the Court observed.

    The Court thus observed that the Tribunal acted correctly, hence there was no reason to intervene in the order of the Tribunal.

    The Original Petition was thus dismissed.

    Counsel for Petitioner: B. Rajesh

    Case Title :  Union of India and Ors. v R. LailaCase Number :  OP(CAT) 182/ 2026CITATION :  2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 635
    Anamika MJ

    Anamika MJ is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering Kerala High Court

    Next Story