Transfer Of Child Custody Case Doesn't Confer Territorial Jurisdiction On Transferee Court: Kerala High Court

  • Transfer Of Child Custody Case Doesnt Confer Territorial Jurisdiction On Transferee Court: Kerala High Court

    The Kerala High Court recently clarified that an order passed under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) transferring a minor's custody petition would not confer territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction on the transferee court. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 637]Justice C.S. Dias observed:“An order under Section 24 of the CPC regulates the forum in which a proceeding is to be tried; it...

    The Kerala High Court recently clarified that an order passed under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) transferring a minor's custody petition would not confer territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction on the transferee court. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 637]

    Justice C.S. Dias observed:

    “An order under Section 24 of the CPC regulates the forum in which a proceeding is to be tried; it does not, by itself, confer territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction on the transferee Court.”

    The Court was considering a plea preferred by a woman seeking to transfer the petition filed by her estranged husband seeking custody for their minor child to the Family Court where she had preferred a separate custody petition.

    The petitioner had moved the Family Court in Irinjalakkuda (Thrissur) seeking permanent custody of the child. Following this, the respondent/husband instituted a similar plea before the Family Court in Aluva (Ernakulam).

    At this juncture, the petitioner approached the High Court stating that she and her 3.5-year-old child are permanent residents of Irinjalakkuda and that it would cause severe hardship and difficulty to travel to Aluva on every posting date. She sought to transfer the plea before Family Court, Aluva to Irinjalakkuda.

    The respondent opposed the transfer plea and contended the petitioner forcibly and unlawfully took the child away from Aluva, where the child was ordinarily residing in. It was also pointed out that prior to the petitioner's plea seeking custody, he had approached the Child Welfare Committee, Ernakulam seeking its intervention and that it was to scuttle the CWC proceedings that she moved the Family Court.

    After hearing the parties, the Court referred to Section 14 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 [Simultaneous proceedings in different Courts]. It observed that when proceedings for appointment/declaration of guardian of a minor is instituted in more than one court and if these courts are subordinate to the same High Court, the proceedings are to be stayed and the High Court is to be reported of the matter to decide which is the court of competent jurisdiction.

    The Court then remarked that in addition to Section 14 of the Act, Section 24 CPC empowers the High Court to transfer proceedings so the two provisions are to be applied harmoniously:

    “In the case of the above nature, the above two provisions are to be applied harmoniously, particularly where the parties advance rival claims as to the child's place of ordinary residence and one party alleges that the child was forcibly and unlawfully removed from the place where the child had been residing.”

    Adverting to the facts of the present case, the Court noted that the parties have raised a dispute regarding the child's ordinary place of residence and the same cannot be resolved in a transfer petition preferred under Section 24 CPC. The Court reasoned that as per Section 9 of the Act, the jurisdiction to entertain an application under the Act is on the court where the minor is ordinarily residing and that “ordinary residence” is a question of fact which the High Court cannot determine while considering transfer petition. It added that it is important to distinguish between the convenience-based exercise of the power of transfer under Section 24 CPC and an adjudication on the territorial jurisdiction of the court before which the proceeding is to be tried.

    Referring to various precedents that lay down that convenience of wife and children is a relevant consideration in deciding transfer petitions and, applying them to the facts of the present case, the Court was of the view that the petitioner ought to be granted relief. It thus allowed the plea.

    The Court directed that the husband's plea be transferred to Family Court, Irinjalakkuda. However, it was made clear that there is no finding that the child is ordinarily residing in the jurisdiction of the transferee court or that the said court has jurisdiction under Section 9.

    "The Family Court, Irinjalakuda, has to decide the objection to its jurisdiction in accordance with law...the transfer of the proceedings by this order shall not be treated as a determination of the question of territorial jurisdiction. If the Family Court, Irinjalakuda, finds that it lacks territorial jurisdiction to entertain the petitions, it shall pass appropriate consequential orders in accordance with law," the Court clarified.

    Counsel for the petitioner: Rahul Sunil, D. Arun Bose, Aromal Sasi

    Counsel for the respondent: Sikha G. Nair

    K. Salma Jennath

    Salma Jennath is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering Kerala High Court

    Next Story