Wife Asking Husband To Go Sleep With His Mother Amounts To Mental Cruelty: Madras High Court Upholds Divorce

  • Wife Asking Husband To Go Sleep With His Mother Amounts To Mental Cruelty: Madras High Court Upholds Divorce

    The Madras High Court recently upheld the order of a Family Court, granting divorce to a couple after noting that the husband was subjected to mental cruelty by the wife. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 550] Justice P Murugan noted that the wife had allegedly used unparliamentary words with the husband, asking him to sleep with his mother. The court noted that cruelty differs from person to person...

    The Madras High Court recently upheld the order of a Family Court, granting divorce to a couple after noting that the husband was subjected to mental cruelty by the wife. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 550]

    Justice P Murugan noted that the wife had allegedly used unparliamentary words with the husband, asking him to sleep with his mother. The court noted that cruelty differs from person to person and is based on the conduct of the person in different situations. In the present case, the court held that the wife's acts amounted to mental cruelty.

    “...no specific explanation was offered by the respondent [wife] with regard to the other expression used by the respondent, asking the petitioner [husband] to go and sleep with his mother. Having the wife treated with this kind of word in the matrimonial life of 24 years beyond, it would amount to cruelty, as per the above decision, cruelty is different from different persons and the conduct of the person in different situation. Therefore, this Court is of the firm view that the acts of the wife towards the husband amounts to mental cruelty,” the court observed.

    The court was hearing an appeal filed by the wife against the order of the Family Court granting divorce.

    The parties had married in 1993 and did not have any children from the marriage. The husband had approached the Family Court seeking divorce under Section 10(1)(x) of the Divorce Act 1869. The husband had argued that since the marriage, the wife had not shown any love and affection to him as a dutiful wife.

    The husband argued that the wife used to suspect his fidelity. He also argued that the wife used unparliamentary language with him and, during a meeting of families, had instigated her family to beat the husband. The husband also submitted that the wife had deserted him since January 2017 saying she did not want to live with him.

    The wife had denied all the allegations and submitted that the husband used to torture her repeatedly. The wife submitted that the husband had bought 2 cents of land by selling her jewels and wanted to give the property to his relatives. The wife submitted that for doing the same, the husband quarrelled with her and left her. The wife submitted that the husband had not given any money towards family needs.

    The court noted that the words used by the wife were unacceptable and would have caused mental agony to the husband. The court also noted that though the wife was advised by the Panchayat, she did not show any willingness or positive attitude for resuming the matrimonial life. The court also noted that the wife had left the matrimonial home in January 2017 and was living away.

    The court opined that the family court had elaborately dealt with the issue and arrived at a right conclusion, which did not necessitate any interference. The court thus dismissed the appeal and upheld the order of divorce.

    Counsel for Appellant: Mr. Fr. S. Savarimuthu for M/s Father Xavier Associates

    Counsel for Respondents: Mr. T. Chandrasekaran

    Upasana Sajeev

    Upasana Sajeev is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering Madras High Court

    Next Story