Meghalaya High Court Summons Senior Police Officer Over Contradictory Claims About CCTV Functioning Before High Court & Supreme Court

  • Meghalaya High Court Summons Senior Police Officer Over Contradictory Claims About CCTV Functioning Before High Court & Supreme Court

    The Meghalaya High Court recently directed the Assistant Inspector General of Police (Admn), Meghalaya, to remain present on November 30, with respect to the alleged discrepancies and statements made on oath before the high court and Supreme Court regarding non-functioning CCTVs in police stations across the State. Earlier, the Court had directed the State to file a comprehensive...

    The Meghalaya High Court recently directed the Assistant Inspector General of Police (Admn), Meghalaya, to remain present on November 30, with respect to the alleged discrepancies and statements made on oath before the high court and Supreme Court regarding non-functioning CCTVs in police stations across the State. 

    Earlier, the Court had directed the State to file a comprehensive affidavit detailing the installation, functioning and maintenance of CCTV cameras in police stations across the State, after prima facie finding non-compliance with the Supreme Court's directions on CCTV surveillance in police stations.

    During the hearing on November 10, a division bench comprising the Chief Justice Revati Mohite Dere and Justice W. Diengdoh observed:

    “Having heard learned counsel for the petitiners, we find some substance in the submissions, so advanced, with respect to discrepancies and statements made on oath before this Court and the Apex Court, and as such, direct Dr. S.R. Marak, Assistant Inspector General of Police (Admn), Meghalaya to remain present on the next date alongwith the files pertaining to the contract awarded of CCTV cameras installations in the Police Stations.”

    The Court further directed AIGP (Admin) to file a detailed affidavit explaining the discrepancies and the non-functioning of CCTV cameras in various Police Stations and the steps that will be taken to ensure that there is compliance with the directions given by the Supreme Court in Paramvir Singh's (2026) case.

    The Amicus Curiae highlighted the discrepancies in the affidavit filed by the Police in the High Court and before the Supreme Court. He submitted that the affidavit filed before the High Court by the Superintendent of Police, Ri Bhoi District, Nongpoh, it has been stated that although, the CCTV system was installed at Nongpoh Police Station at the relevant time, i.e., the time of the incident on June 22, 2026 (alleged violation of human rights of a minor girl which resulted in the minor girl committing suicide following the police interrogation at Women Police Station, Nongpoh) the said CCTV cameras were not functioning.

    It was further pointed that in the said affidavit it has been stated that in Umsning Police Station, 18 CCTV cameras were installed on December 30, 2023 and that all the said CCTV cameras are non-functional since last year; that 15 CCTV cameras were installed in Umiam Police Station on 01.03.2023 and all 15 are non-functional since 23.08.2024 (reason mentioned as power fluctuation).

    Similarly, as far as Nongpoh Police Station and Women Police Station, Nongpoh are concerned, 20 CCTV cameras were installed on July 19, 2021 and all 20 CCTV cameras are non-functional since October 01, 2021, i.e., within 3 months of the installation (reason was no back up of UPS and electricity fluctuation). The affidavit highlighted non-functional status of CCTVs in several other Police Stations except Patharkhmah Police Station where, all 18 CCTV cameras were installed in December, 2023 and all are functional.

    However, it was highlighted that from the affidavit filed by Dr. S.R. Marak, Assistant Inspector General of Police (Admn), Meghalaya, before the Supreme Court on November 14, 2025, is to the contrary. In the said affidavit, it was stated by the process of installation of CCTV cameras in 6 more Police Stations was completed in October, 2023 itself and at present, all Police Stations numbering 81 are equipped with CCTV cameras as per the direction of the Apex Court.

    The Counsel appearing for the petitioner in the PIL also submitted that there are glaring discrepancies in the affidavit filed by the State in this Court and before the Apex Court. He further submitted that he terms of contract, i.e., to whom the contract was awarded for installation of CCTV cameras is not known; whether the contractor was blacklisted is not known; whether the AMC was included in the said contract is not known, etc.

    Thus, the Court directed the AIGP (Admn), Meghalaya to remain present on the next date alongwth the files pertaining to the contract awarded of CCTV cameras installations in the Police Stations. The Court further directed the AIGP (Admn) to file affidavit containing details of the date of installation of the CCTV cameras in the Police Stations, since when they are operational and since when they are non-functional, and the reasons for the same.

    The Court also directed the ASG to file affidavit-in-reply of the NIA, with respect to installation of CCTV in their Office.

    The matter is listed again on November 30.

    Next Story