- Home
- /
- High Courts
- /
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
- /
- Criminal Court Can Add Or Alter...
Criminal Court Can Add Or Alter Charges At Any Stage Before Pronouncement Of Judgment: P&H High Court
Aiman J. Chishti
19 Nov 2026 9:45 AM IST
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has held that power to alter or add a charge under Section 216 CrPC lasts until judgment is pronounced. The Court said that the power is not lost because prosecution evidence has closed and the accused's statement under Section 313 CrPC has been recorded. Justice Neerja K. Kalson observed, “The legal position is thus no longer res integra that the...
This is a premium content
Available exclusively to
Our subscribers
Subscribe Premium
INR 1099+GST
Your support helps us to bring you more content at
an affordable subscription scheme !!!
All payment options available
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has held that power to alter or add a charge under Section 216 CrPC lasts until judgment is pronounced. The Court said that the power is not lost because prosecution evidence has closed and the accused's statement under Section 313 CrPC has been recorded.
Justice Neerja K. Kalson observed, “The legal position is thus no longer res integra that the jurisdiction under Section 216 Cr.P.C. subsists until pronouncement of judgment, irrespective of the stage which the trial may have reached. There exists, however, a fundamental distinction between the continuance of jurisdiction and the justification for its exercise.”
It further added that while the former is preserved by the express language of the statute, the latter must rest upon material prima facie disclosing the ingredients of the proposed offence.
"The power to alter or add a charge is a procedural instrument for ensuring that the accusation corresponds to the offences disclosed by the material; it cannot supply the substantive ingredients of an offence which are otherwise absent from the record."
The Court also held that the mere non-recovery of property that is the subject of a prosecution, or the fact that the accused parted with it, is not enough to add a charge under Section 201 IPC (causing disappearance of evidence). There must be material showing an intention to screen the offender from legal punishment.
The case arose from an FIR registered which was initially registered under Section 420 IPC, and Sections 406 and 506 IPC were added later. The complainant, the petitioner's late father, alleged that the accused (respondent No. 2) had taken gold ornaments worth Rs. 1,94,743 on credit. He alleged that the accused had neither paid for them nor returned them despite repeated demands.
During the investigation, the ornaments were not recovered. The accused stated that he had handed them over to another person. Charges under Sections 420, 406 and 506 IPC were framed in May 2022.
In August 2026, the Assistant Public Prosecutor moved an application on the complainant's behalf to add a charge under Section 201 IPC. The application said the accused had intentionally caused the ornaments to disappear to screen himself from punishment.
The Magistrate dismissed it on reasons that neither the police report nor the inquiry had found that the accused caused the ornaments to disappear; and the application was not maintainable at such an advanced stage, since all prosecution witnesses had been examined and allowing it would mean a retrial.
The petitioner challenged that order under Sections 528 and 529 BNSS and argued that the power under Section 216 lasts until judgment and cannot be cut short because the trial is at an advanced stage. He relied on the accused's own statement that he had handed the ornaments to someone else.
The accused argued that the application came too late. He said the investigating agency had found no material for Section 201, and that mere non-recovery does not amount to disappearance of evidence. He also argued that the power under Section 216 belongs only to the court and cannot be exercised at the complainant's instance.
Relying on P. Kartikalakshmi v. Sri Ganesh (2017), the Court said Section 216 gives the prosecution or the complainant no vested right to demand that a charge be altered or added.
It distinguished between the source of the power and the source of the information that may lead to its use, “While an apparent omission may be brought to the notice of the Court by a party, such an application does not confer an enforceable right to alteration of the charge.
The application furnishes the occasion for consideration; it does not furnish the legal foundation for alteration. That foundation must be discovered, if at all, in the material available before the Court.”
No Fresh Evidence Needed, But Material Must Show The Offence
Citing Dr. Nallapareddy Sridhar Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2020), the Court said a charge can be added at any stage before judgment if the material on record has a direct nexus with the ingredients of the proposed offence.
It held that the power does not depend on new evidence emerging during the trial, “The relevant inquiry is not merely when the material entered the record, but whether such material, considered in its proper perspective, prima facie discloses the constituent ingredients of the charge sought to be added.”
Police Opinion Not Binding
The Court said the investigating agency's view of which offences are made out does not limit the court's independent jurisdiction.
“The police report represents the conclusion reached by the investigating agency; it does not constitute the final judicial determination of the offences for which an accused may be required to stand trial. The investigative conclusion may inform the judicial determination, but it cannot supplant it.”
It added that this independence “does not authorise addition of a charge in the absence of material disclosing its statutory ingredients.”
The Court also pointed to the safeguards in Sections 216(3), 216(4) and 217 CrPC, which allow for an adjournment, a new trial, or the recall of witnesses.
“Procedural fairness is not antithetical to the power of alteration; it is an indispensable condition governing its exercise.”
Trial Court Wrong On Stage, Right On Merits
The Court disagreed with the trial court's view that the application was not maintainable at a late stage.
“The fact that the prosecution evidence has concluded and the statement of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. stands recorded does not, by itself, divest the Court of such jurisdiction. Indeed, the statutory scheme expressly contemplates the procedural consequences which may follow alteration or addition of a charge, including the necessity of affording an adequate opportunity to the accused to meet the altered accusation.”
On Section 201 IPC, the Court held that the required intention to screen the offender “cannot be presumed merely from the circumstance that property forming the subject matter of a prosecution remains unrecovered.” It said:
“Even apart from the evidentiary limitations attaching to a statement recorded during police investigation, the mere parting with or non-recovery of property, without material prima facie indicating the requisite intention contemplated under Section 201 IPC, cannot by itself furnish a sufficient foundation for addition of the proposed charge. To hold otherwise would be to conflate the subject matter of the alleged offence with the distinct criminal act which Section 201 IPC seeks to punish.”
It added that “the mere insistence upon addition of a charge cannot compensate for the absence of material prima facie satisfying its independent statutory ingredients.”
The Court therefore upheld the order even though one of its two reasons was wrong.
“An order which is otherwise sustainable upon substantive grounds does not necessarily warrant interference merely because one of the reasons assigned in its support is legally untenable. In the absence of a sufficient prima facie foundation for the proposed charge, setting aside the impugned order merely to direct reconsideration would serve no meaningful purpose.”
In the light of the above, the petition was dismissed.
Mr. Prateek Gupta, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Jatinder Pal Singh, Sr. DAG, Punjab.
Tags
Aiman J. Chishti
Aiman J. Chishti is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering Punjab And Haryana High Court


