Delhi Govt Also Asks Same: Punjab Govt To High Court On Voter ID Requirement To Avail Women's Scheme Benefits
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK
19 Nov 2026 4:44 PM IST

The Punjab government on Thursday, while defending its decision that voter identity cards mandatory for grant of benefits under the 'Mukh Mantri Mawan Dheeyan Satkar Yojana,' a financial assistance scheme to provide monthly income to women, submitted that the same is also asked by the Delhi Government in a scheme for women.
Senior Advocate Vikas Singh for state, made submissions before Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor that other State governments also require the beneficiaries to submit their voter ID cards for verification purpose.
However, Chief Justice orally remarked that, "whether it is this government or that...We are on a simple issue. What is the justification? What is the requirement."
Singh further submitted that voter ID is the only document to show a person is a genuine resident of a particular area and added that the State would file a better affidavit as in its earlier reply, it had only referred to the practice of other States.
The petitioner was stated to be a charitable society and filed the PIL challenging Mukh Mantri Mawan Dheeyan Satkar Yojana notified on 02.04.2026 on the ground that the purpose of the scheme is only to secure votes in favour of the ruling dispensation. Clause 9 of the Scheme is highlighted which specifies the documentation required to avail benefit under the Scheme.
Under the scheme, women in Punjab who are registered voters receive monthly financial assistance, Rs 1,500 for women from the Scheduled Castes and Rs 1,000 for other women.
It was submitted that mandatory requirement of Voter ID card of Punjab State, issued by the Election Commission of India for availing benefit under the Scheme clearly indicates that object of Scheme is only to secure votes from the beneficiaries.
It was further contended that Voter ID card can be one of the documents required for the purposes of identification etc., but requiring it mandatorily for the grant of benefit under the Scheme manifests its purpose i.e., to act as a quid pro quo for securing votes.
Mr. Varun Dutta, Advocate and Mr. Karan Bhardwaj, Advocate for the petitioner.

