P&H High Court Rejects Woman's Plea To Transfer Case After Finding She Falsely Claimed Her Deceased Father Was Bedridden

  • P&H High Court Rejects Womans Plea To Transfer Case After Finding She Falsely Claimed Her Deceased Father Was Bedridden

    The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed a woman's application to transfer a civil suit filed against her by her brother-in-law. It found that her main ground, that her father was sick and bedridden, was false, because her father had died years before her marriage.Justice Mandeep Pannu held, “Thus, the applicant has made a false averment regarding the illness and bedridden condition...

    The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed a woman's application to transfer a civil suit filed against her by her brother-in-law. It found that her main ground, that her father was sick and bedridden, was false, because her father had died years before her marriage.

    Justice Mandeep Pannu held, “Thus, the applicant has made a false averment regarding the illness and bedridden condition of her father who was already dead at the time of filing of the present transfer application, which constitutes concealment of a material fact having a direct bearing on the relief sought in the present application.”

    The respondent, the applicant's brother-in-law, had filed a civil suit against her for recovery of damages before the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Phillaur. She sought its transfer to a court at Mukerian, District Hoshiarpur, on the ground that she lives in Village Ghaseetpur, Tehsil Mukerian, about 120 km one way from Phillaur.

    It was submitted that a maintenance petition under Section 144 BNSS between her and her husband was pending at Mukerian. She was living with her parents, and her father was poor, sick and bedridden.

    She had no independent income and could not easily travel alone to Phillaur.

    The respondent opposed the application. He argued that the applicant works as a nurse and earns about ₹30,000 a month and the FIR under Section 498-A IPC (Section 85 BNS) that she had lodged named only her husband, not the respondent, it added.

    The Mukerian proceedings were between her and her husband and did not involve him. She had concealed material facts, because her father had died about seven or eight years earlier.

    Wedding Card Belies Claim

    The Court found that the respondent's claim was supported by the wedding invitation card he had placed on record. The card described the applicant as “Shivani D/o Smt. Shakuntla Devi w/o Late Sh. Lakhwinder”.

    The Court said a litigant seeking discretionary relief must come to court with clean hands:

    “It is well settled that a litigant seeking discretionary relief from the Court is required to approach the Court with clean hands and make a full and fair disclosure of all material facts. Suppression or misrepresentation of material facts disentitles a party from claiming such relief. In the present case, the applicant has not only suppressed a material fact but has also sought to seek advantage on the basis of a factually incorrect assertion.”

    Holding that the applicant was not entitled to the discretionary relief of transfer, the Court dismissed the application.

    Mr. Sunil Agnihotri, Advocate for the applicant.

    Ms. Shruti Mandhotra, Advocate for the respondent.

    Aiman J. Chishti

    Aiman J. Chishti is a Principal Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering Punjab And Haryana High Court

    Next Story