When Can NCLAT Remand Resolution Plan To CoC? Supreme Court Explains

  • NCLAT | Supreme Court

    CoC does not become functus officio after approving a plan, the Court added.

    Listen to this Article

    While upholding the power of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal to remand the approved resolution plan to the Committee of Creditors, the Supreme Court on Monday (November 16) laid down the considerations that ought to guide the NCLAT when remanding an approved resolution plan to the CoC.

    A Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe held that remanding the matter would be the most viable option available to the NCLAT while examining a challenge to the approval of a resolution plan. The Court explained that the NCLAT cannot modify a resolution plan or substitute its own commercial judgment for that of the CoC. At the same time, outright rejection of a plan may push the corporate debtor into liquidation, which the IB Code treats as a measure of last resort.

    The Court observed that either upholding a non-compliant resolution plan or rejecting it altogether could push the corporate debtor into liquidation, defeating the objectives of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (“IBC”).

    “The necessity (of remand) becomes apparent from the structure of the appellate remedy itself. An appeal against an order approving a resolution plan lies only on the grounds enumerated in Section 61(3), and the NCLAT, confined to those grounds, may either dismiss the appeal or allow it. If the appeal is allowed, the only consequence, absent a remand, is that the approval is set aside. Where the CIRP period has run its course, such setting aside would ordinarily push the corporate debtor towards liquidation, the very outcome the Legislature has sought to avoid. A binary choice between affirming a non-compliant plan and setting it aside altogether would thus place the Appellate Authority at odds with the objectives it is meant to serve.”, the Court observed.

    The Court laid down following considerations that would guide the exercise the power of remand by the NCLAT:

    a) The power of remand is to be exercised only in furtherance of the objectives of the Code, namely, keeping the corporate debtor a going concern, ensuring a fair and reasonable recovery for all classes of creditors, and maximising the value of the corporate debtor's assets during the CIRP. A remand that advances none of these objectives is not justified merely because the power to order it exists.

    b) Remand must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance, whether under Section 30(2) or under any other law within the meaning of Section 61(3)(i). This follows from the confined grounds on which an appeal against an approved resolution plan lies.

    c) Remand is to be exercised sparingly and with circumspection, and not in a manner that departs from any express procedure prescribed under the Code, consistent with the limitations laid down by this Court on the exercise of inherent and implied powers to do justice.

    d) Remand also serves a corrective function. Where the Adjudicating Authority, on encountering a curable defect in a resolution plan placed before it for approval under Section 31, proceeds to modify the plan in exercise of its own discretion instead of remitting it to the CoC, the NCLAT may remand the plan so as to restore the allocation of roles between the Adjudicating Authority and the CoC.

    e) Since a speedy and time-bound resolution is itself an objective of the Code, any order of remand must be accompanied by a strict direction to adhere to the timelines prescribed under the Code and the relevant regulations, so that the remedy does not itself become a source of the very delay that the Code seeks to avoid.

    The Court made these observations while dismissing appeals filed by Twinstar Technologies Limited, the successful resolution applicant in the insolvency proceedings concerning Videocon Industries Limited and twelve other group companies. The appeals challenged the NCLAT's decision to set aside approval of Twinstar's resolution plan and remit the matter to the CoC.

    The insolvency proceedings arose from the consolidated Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) of Videocon Industries Limited and twelve other group companies.

    Twinstar's resolution plan, involving a financial outlay of approximately ₹2,962 crore, was approved by 95.09% of the CoC's voting share. However, three dissenting financial creditors Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI Limited and SIDBI challenged its approval before the NCLAT.

    The creditors objected, among other things, to the proposed payment through non-convertible debentures (NCDs), which were redeemable over a period extending up to six years. They argued that this did not satisfy the requirement of payment to dissenting financial creditors under Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC.

    The NCLAT accepted the objection, set aside the approval of the resolution plan and remitted the matter to the CoC for completion of the CIRP in accordance with the Code. Twinstar challenged this decision before the Supreme Court.

    Dismissing the appeals, the judgment authored by Justice Aradhe said that where a plan is found to be non-compliant, the adjudicating authorities cannot themselves alter its terms to cure the defect, hence referring to its earlier decisions in Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v. NBCC (India) Ltd. and Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta, the Court reiterated that a defective resolution plan must be sent back to the CoC so that the resolution applicant may make necessary modifications and the CoC may reconsider and vote on the revised plan.

    The Court also explained that rejecting a resolution plan under Section 31(2) could trigger liquidation under Section 33(1)(b). Since liquidation is treated as a measure of last resort under the IBC, remand provides an opportunity to rectify the defect while preserving the possibility of resolution.

    CoC does not become functus officio after approving a plan

    The Court also addressed the issue regarding the authority of the CoC after approving the resolution plan. It was contended by the appellant that the post-approval of the resolution plan, the CoC becomes functus officio, thereby making it ineligible to rectify the defect in the plan.

    Rejecting such an argument, the Court held that the CoC does not become functus officio merely because it has approved a resolution plan. It remains in existence throughout the CIRP and continues to discharge its statutory responsibilities until the plan is implemented or an order of liquidation is passed.

    The Court noted that the approval of Appellant-Twinstar's plan had not attained finality, as it was challenged in statutory appeals and the NCLAT had stayed the approval and directed maintenance of status quo ante. In these circumstances, the CoC was entitled to seek reconsideration of the plan.

    It distinguished Ebix Singapore Pvt. Ltd. v. Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions Ltd., observing that the case concerned a resolution applicant seeking to withdraw or modify its plan, whereas the present matter involved reconsideration of a plan found to be non-compliant with the Code.

    As a result, the appeals were dismissed.

    Appearances:

    For Appellant(s) : Mr. Maninder Singh, Sr. Adv. Mr. K K Venugopal, Sr. Adv. Mr. Guru Krishna Kumar, Sr. Adv. Mr. Gopal Shankarnarayan, Sr. Adv. Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, A.S.G. Mr. Gaurav Singh, Adv. Mr. Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary- 2270, AOR Mr. Guru Krishna Kumar, Sr. Adv. Mr. Diwakar Maheshwari, Adv. Mr. Shreyas Edupuganti, Adv. Ms. Pratiksha Mishra, Adv. Mr. Shubham Saini, Adv. Mr. Karun Mehta- 1972, AOR Ms. Daizy Chawala, Adv. Mr. Himanshu Dubey, Adv. Mr. Jatin Kapoor, Adv. Mr. Siddhant Singh, Adv. Mr. Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary- 2270, AOR Mr. K. R. Sasiprabhu- 895, AOR Mrs. Prabhleen Apoorv Shukla- 3782, AOR Mr. Soumik Ghosal- 2373, AOR Mr. Abhishek Singh, Adv. Mr. Kartik Dey, Adv. Mr. Rishav Rai, Adv. Ms. Anuja Tiwari, Adv. Mr. Shikhar Thukral, Adv. Ms. Aparna Tiwari, Adv. Mr. Amitesh Chandra Mishra, Adv. Ms. Vishakha, Adv. Mr. Mrityunjai Singh, Adv. Mr. Prashant Kumar Mishra, Adv. Mr. Abhijnan Jha- 3209 , AOR Mr. Sandeep S Ladda, Adv. Mrs. Prabhleen Apoorv Shukla, AOR Mr. Sandeep S Ladda, Adv. Mr. Soumik Ghosal, AOR Ms. Chinmayee, Adv. Ms. Rohini Srinivasan, Adv. Mr. Ashutosh Chaturvedi, Adv. Mrs. Prabhleen Apoorv Shukla- 3782, AOR

    For Respondent(s) : Mr. Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General Mr. N Venkatraman, A.S.G. Mr. Niranjan Reddy, Sr. Adv. Mr. Shashank Garg, Sr. Adv. Mr. Nakul Dewan, Sr. Adv. Ms. Anindita Roychowdhury, Adv. Ms. Vatsala Rai, Adv. Mr. Abhijnan Jha- 3209, AOR Mr. Abhijnan Jha- 3209 , AOR Mr. Madhav Kanoria, Adv. Ms. Surabhi Khattar, Adv. Ms. Neha Shivhare, Adv. Mr. Shivansh Vishwakarma, Adv. Ms. Pallavi Agarwal, Adv. Mr. Vikash Kumar Jha, Adv. M/S. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, AOR Mr. Vaijayant Paliwal, Adv. Ms. Moulshree Shukla, Adv. Ms. Ms. Gayathri Balasubramanian, Adv. Ms. Charu Bansal, Adv. Mr. S. S. Shroff- 710, AOR Mr. Soumik Ghosal- 2373, AOR Mr. Abhinav Agrawal- 2630, AOR Mr. Tanuj Sud, Adv. Mr. Ajay Kumar, Adv. Ms. Stuti Vatsa, Adv. Mr. Vijayant Goel, Adv. Mr. Abhikalp Pratap Singh, AOR Mr. N. Venkataraman, A.S.G. Mr. Badri Prasad Singh- 114, AOR Mr. S. Niranjan Reddy, Sr. Adv. Mr. Vaijayant Paliwal, Adv. Ms. Charu Bansal, Adv. Ms. Moulshree Shukla, Adv. Ms. Gayathri Balasubramanian, Adv. Mr. S. S. Shroff- 710, AOR Mr. P. K. Jain- 505, AOR Mr. Saurabh Jain, Adv. Mr. Karun Mehta- 1972, AOR Ms. Varuna Bhanrale, Adv. Ms. Ananya Sinha, Adv. Mr. Shahid Khan, Adv. M/s Trilegal Advocates On Record- 3376, AOR Mr. Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General Mr. Madhav Kanoria, Adv. Ms. Surabhi Khattar, Adv. Ms. Srideepa Bhattacharyya, Adv. Ms. Neha Shivhare, Adv. Mr. Shivansh Vishwakarma, Adv. Ms. Pallavi Agarwal, Adv. Ms. Pallavi Agrawal, Adv. Mr. Vikash Kumar Jha, Adv. M/S. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas Aor- 2238, AOR Mr. K. R. Sasiprabhu- 895, AOR Mr. Sumant Nayak, Adv. Mr. Aslam Ahmed Jamal, AOR Mr. Rohit Jain, Adv. Ms. Shraddha Chaudhari, Adv. Ms. Smriti Shukla, Adv. Ms. Ankita Sharma, Adv. Mr. Abhishek Dwivedi, Adv. Ms. Farha Naaz, Adv. Ms. Shaila Arora, Adv. Ms. Divyansha, Adv. Mr. Zeeshan Haider, Adv. Mr. Shubhanshu Gupta- 3448, AOR Mr. Soumik Ghosal- 2373, AOR Mr. Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary- 2270, AOR Mr. N Venkatraman, A.S.G. Ms. Anindita Roychowdhury, Adv. Ms. Vatsala Rai, Adv. Mr. Abhijnan Jha- 3209, AOR Mr. Manoj K. Mishra, AOR Mr. Umesh Dubey, Adv. Ms. Madhulika, Adv. Mr. Amrendra Kumar Singh, Adv. Mr. Amulya Dev Mishra, Adv. Ms. Shriji Mishra, Adv. Mr. Shashank Tiwari, Adv. Mr. Sarthak Tiwari, Adv. Mr. Piyush Joshi, Adv. Ms. Sumiti Yadava, Adv. Ms. Vatsla Bhatia, Adv. Ms. Aarshia Biju Shantharam, Adv. Ms. Sonakshi Malhan, AOR Mr. Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar- 1593, AOR

    Case Title :  TWINSTAR TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED VERSUS BANK OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS.CITATION :  2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1152
    Yash Mittal

    Yash Mittal is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Supreme Court of India

    Next Story