Supreme Court Mulls Asking State Judicial Academies To Scan HC Judgments For Objectionable Remarks In Sexual Offence Cases
Debby Jain
16 Nov 2026 8:04 PM IST

The Supreme Court today expressed an inclination to direct judicial academies across the country to conduct a survey of High Court observations that were offensive to women, so the High Courts can ultimately be directed to take up suo motu cases and expunge the observations.
A bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana was dealing with the suo motu case taken up over a Patna High Court judgment which held that allegations of attempting to remove a woman's salwar and physically molesting by pressing her chest do not constitute an 'attempt to rape'.
Earlier, the bench had noted that the High Court's observations were 'offensive'. It was particularly surprised as the underlying Patna High Court judgment containing offending observations came despite the Court having taken up a suo motu case, set aside a similar Allahabad High Court verdict (containing offending observations) and issued guidelines on judges sensitively handling sexual offense cases.
At the outset of today's hearing, the CJI expressed an inclination to intervene and expunge the objectionable remarks in the Patna High Court judgment.
However, Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta stressed that the issue was not limited to only one Patna High Court judgment. She underlined that the Court had issued notice qua 3 more controversial orders [two passed after the SC order setting aside the Allahabad High Court verdict].
Gupta referred to the case of V Tulasamma & Ors v. V Sesha Reddi (Dead) By LRs (1977), decided by a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court, where the Court overruled 150 High Court judgments and observed that property given to a Hindu widow in recognition of her pre-existing right to maintenance becomes her absolute property.
She highlighted that 150 judgments were set aside in the said case, noting that interpretation of law therein was not correct. “These observations are so troubling. I was just doing the research. Since 1959 onwards the observations…”, Gupta submitted.
When counsel for accused-Himanshu Pathak entered appearance and sought time to file a reply, the Court adjourned the matter and gave him 1 week's time.
“Remind us that we have to direct judicial academies of every state to undertake a survey of all the judgments made by respective High Courts and find out the offending parts. Thereafter, we will direct the High Courts to take suo motu and erase [the observations]” CJI conveyed to Gupta.
Gupta then added that some order would have to be passed as there are some judgments of the Supreme Court as well, where “facts are shocking” but still the issue has been “poised down” as if there was an “extreme case of molestation” or “outraging of modesty”.
The CJI observed that if there is a similar issue with Supreme Court judgments, it would be difficult for the bench to issue a direction. “We may have to have another recourse. It's not that there is no remedy” the CJI said.
In the context of the Tulsamma judgment, when CJI distinguished between consequences of setting aside decisions in civil matters vis-à-vis criminal matters, Gupta clarified that she was not seeking setting aside of the High Court decisions.
“In Tulsamma, my lords had set aside 150 judgments by saying that view taken was not correct. I am not saying set aside those judgments. But making an observation that view taken was not correct…interpretation of law whether it is...I am on that only. Because once that law is settled then this would be…” she urged.
“That we can do”, CJI replied, asking her to give a compilation of the judgments.
The bench also issued notice in a connected case, where Bihar Advocate General SD Sanjay appeared.

