Criminal Law

'Case Of The Victim Cannot Be Totally Neglected': Bombay High Court Upholds Categorization Of Woman Convict In Stricter Category For Remission
The Bombay High Court has upheld the classification of a woman convicted of participating in the dowry death of another woman under the remission category dealing with crimes against women, rather than the category dealing with crimes committed by women. The Court observed that the case of the victim cannot be totally neglected, and a beneficial interpretation cannot provide a way for...

Non-Production Of Malkhana Register Alone Cannot Vitiate NDPS Conviction: Tripura High Court Upholds 10-Year Jail Term In 987 Kg Ganja Case
The Tripura High Court has held that mere non-production of the Malkhana register before the trial court cannot be a ground to discard a prosecution case under the NDPS Act, 1985, when the identity, integrity and safe custody of the seized contraband are otherwise established. The Court observed that in the absence of any material indicating tampering, substitution or a break in the chain...

Telangana High Court Laments 'Rubber Stamp' Cognizance Orders Passed By Magistrates, Directs Judicial Training
The Telangana High Court has recently expressed concern over Magistrates taking cognizance of offences by 'using rubber stamps' and passing 'routine and mechanical orders', while noting that the court had set aside more than 500 such cognizance orders since January 2026. [2026 LiveLaw (Tel) 164]“…Since January 2026, this Court has set aside more than 500 cognizance orders. In those...

Fixed Sentence Of 20 Years Can Ordinarily Be Suspended During Appeal: Sikkim High Court Grants Bail To POCSO Convict
The Sikkim High Court has suspended the sentence of a 24-year-old man convicted under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act and granted him bail pending appeal, observing that where a sentence is for a fixed term, the appellate court may ordinarily exercise its discretion to suspend its operation liberally, unless exceptional circumstances exist.Division Bench...

Meghalaya High Court Quashes POCSO Case Against Man, Cites Survivor's No-Objection As They Live Together With Their 6-Year-Old Son
The Meghalaya High Court has quashed a POCSO case registered against a 25-year-old man after finding that the 22-year-old survivor had given her informed consent to quashing the proceedings and was voluntarily living with him along with their six-year-old son. The Court observed that in exceptional cases involving consensual adolescent relationships resulting in marriage or cohabitation...

27-Year-Old Status Quo Order Still Binding; Rajasthan High Court Holds Respondents Guilty Of Contempt
The Rajasthan High Court has held that pendency of appeal since 1999, and respondents' claim that they could not remain in regular touch with the lawyers due to long pendency, was not an acceptable justification to undertake construction on a property, in relation to which there was a subsisting direction of maintaining status quo. While holding the respondents guilty of contempt of court...

After Gorkha Association Says It Won't Pursue Case, Sikkim High Court Quashes Non-Compoundable BNS Charges Against Two Men
The Sikkim High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against two men accused under Section 196(1)(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, which deals with promoting enmity between different groups, after the Bharatiya Gorkha Parisangh (Sikkim State Branch) informed the Court that it did not wish to pursue the case further. The Court held that, considering the nature of the offences,...

Karnataka High Court Upholds POCSO Acquittal, Says Minor Girl Had 'Enough Worldly Knowledge'
The Karnataka High Court at Kalaburagi upheld the acquittal of a man accused of kidnapping and repeatedly raping a minor girl, noting that the facts showed the girl had enough worldly knowledge and was in the habit of having love affairs and extracting money. The Division Bench of Justice Ashok S. Kinagi and Justice Subramanya reiterated the principle set out by Apex Court that an order...

Kanhaiya Lal Murder Case: Rajasthan High Court Upholds UAPA Charges Against Eight Accused
Absence of direct evidence of conspiracy cannot be decisive, Court said.

Orissa High Court Rejects Quashing Plea, Imposes ₹50K Costs On Accused For Suppressing Anticipatory Bail Rejection Orders
The Orissa High Court, while dismissing a petition seeking to quash an impending criminal proceeding, has imposed an exemplary cost of rupees fifty thousand on an accused person for deliberately suppressing adverse orders passed against him earlier by both the High Court and the Supreme Court in anticipatory bail pleas. [2026 LiveLaw (Ori) 125]While discarding the argument that an accused is...

Karnataka High Court Refuses To Quash Criminal Defamation Case Against Maneka Gandhi, But Stays Trial Court Summons For 2 Weeks
The Karnataka High Court has dismissed a petition filed by politician and former Union Minister Maneka Sanjay Gandhi, seeking to quash criminal defamation proceedings pending against her before the trial court based on a private complaint as well as summons issued to her. The case stems from a private complaint filed by one S.K. Mittal alleging offences under Sections 499 and 500 of the...

Allegations Of Outraging Modesty Of Woman Can Be Sustained Even If Victim Is Transgender Woman: Bombay High Court
The offence of outraging modesty of a woman punishable under section 75 of the Bharatiya Nyay Sanhita (BNS) can be sustained even when the victim is a transgender person, who identifies herself as a woman, held the Bombay High Court recently. Single-judge Justice Mehroz Pathan in an order passed on November 3, refused to discharge one Vishal Ingle, who served in Indian Army as an Agniveer. He...
