Widow's Subsequent 'Unchastity' Can't Divest Her Of Property Inherited From Deceased Husband: MP High Court
Jayanti Pahwa
16 Nov 2026 5:00 PM IST

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has held that a widow cannot be deprived of property inherited from her deceased husband merely because she subsequently started living with another man, observing that once inheritance rights have vested in her under the Hindu law applicable at the relevant time, subsequent 'unchastity' cannot extinguish those rights. [2026 LiveLaw (MP) 462]
The bench of Justice Pranay Verma upheld a widow's entitlement to a one-third share in the disputed land, noting that she had started living with her deceased husband's brother only a few years after her husband's death.
Referring to paragraph 96 of Hindu Law by Mulla, 25th Edition, the Court observed that under the law applicable before the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, a widow's chastity at the time of her husband's death was relevant to her right to inherit his estate. However, once the property vested in her, she could not be divested of it because of subsequent unchastity.
The Court observed:
"As per paragraph 96 of Hindu Law by Mulla, 25th Edition, a widow who is unchaste at the time of her husband's death is not entitled to inherit his estate but once the husband's estate has vested in her, which could only be if she was chaste at the time of his death, it cannot be divested by her subsequent unchastity."
It further held that the widow had inherited her husband's estate as a limited owner and subsequently became its absolute owner upon the enactment of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
The Court was hearing a second appeal filed by the defendants challenging concurrent judgments of the trial court and the first appellate court, which had declared the plaintiff-widow entitled to a one-third share in the disputed land.
The land originally belonged to one Sadhuwa, who had four sons — Gopaliya, Lalli, Saheba and Ramshel.
The plaintiff was initially married to Gopaliya, who died issueless in 1950. Thereafter, according to the prevailing caste customs, she started living with his brother Lalli as his wife, and they had a daughter. Following Lalli's death, she started living with another brother, Saheba, as his wife.
The plaintiff claimed that she had inherited a one-third share in the land following Lalli's death and that her name was recorded alongside the other co-owners in the revenue records. However, the defendants allegedly partitioned the land among themselves, excluding her share.
The defendants contended that since the plaintiff had subsequently married Saheba according to caste customs, she could claim a share only through him and could not assert inheritance rights as Lalli's widow.
The courts below rejected this contention, finding that Saheba was already married when the plaintiff started living with him and that his earlier marriage had not been dissolved through customary divorce. Consequently, the plaintiff's alleged marriage with Saheba was not legally valid, and she continued to retain her status as Lalli's widow.
Upholding these findings, the High Court noted that the defendants had neither pleaded nor established that Saheba had divorced his first wife, Kamli, according to caste customs.
The Court observed that even under the Hindu law prevailing before the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, Saheba could not have legally married the plaintiff while his earlier marriage subsisted.
It therefore held that the alleged marriage with Saheba did not alter the plaintiff's status as Lalli's widow.
Addressing the contention regarding the plaintiff's subsequent 'unchastity', the Court noted that she had not been living with Saheba at the time of Lalli's death. Even according to the defendants, she started residing with Saheba only a few years later.
The Court held:
"Since she was not unchaste at the time of death of Lalli, she inherited his estate, though as a limited estate but upon coming into force of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, became the absolute owner thereof and is entitled to claim share in the suit land accordingly."
Finding no illegality in the concurrent judgments granting the plaintiff a one-third share in the land, the High Court dismissed the second appeal.
For the appellants: Advocate Ranno Rajak.

