LiveLaw Madras High Court Weekly Roundup: November 9 to November 15, 2026
Upasana Sajeev
17 Nov 2026 9:05 AM IST

Citations: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 538 To 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 544
NOMINAL INDEX
S v U, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 538
J v The Commissioner of Police and Others, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 539
A. Shahul Hameed v State of Tamil Nadu and Others, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 540
D Rakesh v The Union of India and Others, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 541
Udhayanidhi Stalin v P Milany, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 542
M. Sangeetha v The State, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 543
B Ramkumar Aditya v The Secretary, 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 544
REPORT
Women Seeking Maintenance For Children Cannot Be Labelled 'Gold Diggers': Madras High Court
Case Title: S v U
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 538
The Madras High Court recently held that the dignity of a woman cannot be attacked merely for seeking maintenance which is legally due to her child. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 538]
Justice MD Sumathi added that the end of a marriage does not end the father's responsibility. The court also added that a mother's ability to earn would not diminish the father's responsibility.
The court also expressed strong disapproval in the manner in which women, seeking maintenance, were being termed as “gold-diggers”. The court held that such expressions shift the attention from the actual question of legal responsibility and try to put the character of the woman on trial, rather than the merits of the claim.
The court added that a woman would have to take up multiple responsibilities after the breakdown of marriage. It remarked that when such a woman approached the court seeking legal maintenance for the legitimate needs of the child, terming her a “gold-digger” is not just demeaning but reflects the deeply unfair attitude towards the responsibilities undertaken by her after marriage.
Being Natural Guardian Doesn't Entitle Father To Take Child's Custody By Force: Madras High Court
Case Title: J v The Commissioner of Police and Others
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 539
The Madras High Court recently held that a father, though being a natural guardian of a minor child, cannot take the child's custody by force and should seek custody only in accordance with the procedure established by law. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 539]
The bench of Justice AD Jagadish Chandira and Justice B Karthikeyan thus directed a father to hand over his 2.5-year-old minor child to the mother.
Case Title: A. Shahul Hameed v State of Tamil Nadu and Others
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 540
The Madras High Court recently flagged the pendency of corruption cases throughout the state of Tamil Nadu and directed the State Government to take appropriate steps for setting up special courts. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 540]
Noting that 2423 cases were pending throughout the state of Tamil Nadu and an additional 61 cases were pending in Puducherry, Justice B Pugalendhi has asked the state government to consult with the High Court with respect to setting up special courts considering district-wise pendency, and take appropriate steps for the same.
The court also directed the state to extend all necessary cooperation to the High Court administration in providing the required infrastructure, supporting staff and other facilities for effective functioning of the existing Special Courts.
Case Title: D Rakesh v The Union of India and Others
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 541
The Madras High Court recently dismissed a Public Interest Litigation alleging that “Vimal Pan Masala” was being promoted under the “Vimal Elaichi” advertisement. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 541]
The bench of Chief Justice SA Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan held that the petitioner's case rested on speculations and internet rumours and the court's jurisdiction could not be set in motion in the absence of credible material.
Case Title: Udhayanidhi Stalin v P Milany
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 542
The Madras High Court, on Friday (November 13), dismissed an application filed by the Leader of Opposition in the State of Tamil Nadu, Udhayanidhi Stalin, seeking to reject an election petition challenging his victory from the Chepauk Assembly Constituency. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 542]
Dismissing his application, Justice G Arul Murugan directed Udhayanidhi to file his counter affidavit in the election petition within 4 weeks.
Surgical Needle Found In Woman's Abdomen 12 Years After Surgery: Madras High Court Orders Probe
Case Title: M. Sangeetha v The State
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 543
The Madras High Court has directed the Tamil Nadu Medical Council to conduct an enquiry after a woman alleged that a surgical needle was left inside her abdomen in a surgery, conducted 12 years ago. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 543]
Justice PT Asha was not willing to accept the doctor's argument that the woman had approached the court belatedly. The court noted that the woman belonged to lower strata of society and her economic condition did not permit her to take medical treatment for abdominal pain earlier.
The court also noted that the intra-operative report showed the presence of a needle which showed the careless manner in which the surgery was performed. The court thus opined that the matter required investigation and the woman's suffering could not be ignored just because she approached the court belatedly.
Plea To Disclose Tax Levied In Petrol, Diesel Bills Withdrawn From Madras High Court
Case Title: B Ramkumar Aditya v The Secretary
Citation: 2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 544
A plea calling upon the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas to ensure that the bills issued by petrol/diesel outlets and the display board in the outlets contain the details of the tax levied has been withdrawn from the Madras High Court. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 544]
A submission was made before the bench of Chief Justice SA Dharmadhikari and Justice P Velmurugan seeking leave of court to withdraw the plea. The court permitted withdrawal, with liberty to work out remedy as per law. The court had previously issued notice to the Ministry on the plea.
The petition, filed by Advocate B Ramkumar Adityan, stated that knowing the tax on a product was a part of the consumer's right to information and protection against unfair trade practices, as per the Consumer Protection Act. it has been submitted that the consumers should have all the necessary details to make informed decisions and should not be misled or exploited by sellers.
OTHER DEVELOPMENTS
Case Title: V Ramasubbu v Dr K Gopal and Another
Case Number: Cont P (MD) 3763 of 2026
The Madras High Court, on Tuesday (November 10), directed the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption to register an FIR in connection with the alleged scam in the procurement of books for public libraries. The court has also directed the authorities to take necessary steps to freeze the bank account of alleged fraudulent publishers.
The scam relates to alleged procurement of “AI-generated” books purchased for public libraries in the state. The matter came to light when renowned writer Perumal Murugan published an article exposing the incident. Later, TN School Education Minister A Rajmohan, recently accused the previous government of procuring poor quality books containing fabricated information, from a single publisher— Agal Vilakku Pathippagam.
The bench of Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi passed the interim orders on a contempt petition filed by an advocate, Ramasubbu, alleging non-compliance with an earlier order of the court with respect to procurement of books for public libraries.
Case Title: H Syed Alim v The Director General of Police
Case Number: WP No 44784 of 2026
The Madras High Court, on Wednesday (November 11), directed the Director General of Police to reply to a plea seeking a Police Standing Order or Circular prescribing uniform, lawful safeguards for police stations, cybercrime units and investigating officers while dealing with complaints relating to social media posts, political criticism, satire, and online speech.
The bench of Chief Justice SA Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan issued notice to the DGP and directed him to file a reply within 2 weeks.
When the case was being heard, Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani informed the court that two similar petitions were pending before a single judge. He also informed the court that the State was promulgating an SOP and the process had already begun. He added that many aspects had to be considered, which would be taken note of while issuing the SOP. The bench then directed him to file a reply to the present plea detailing the aspects.
Case Title: Archana Veeramani v The Immigration Officer and Others
Case Number: WP Crl No 3026 of 2026
The Madras High Court has directed the Special Investigation Team, constituted to investigate the POCSO case involving granite baron Veeramani, to respond to a plea filed by his daughter, Archana Veeramani, against her alleged illegal detention and human rights violation.
When the plea came up before Justice V Lakshminarayanan on Wednesday (November 11), Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani requested the court to grant time to file a response to the plea and to place the facts before the court. Accepting the request, the court adjourned the plea to Tuesday (November 17).
Archana has moved the court to quash a summons issued to her under Section 35(3) of the BNSS and to direct investigation into the alleged human rights violation.
Case Title: V Ramasubbu v Dr K Gopal and Another
Case Number: Cont P (MD) 3763 of 2026
The State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan, on Wednesday (November 11), informed the Madras High Court that the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption will register an FIR in connection with an alleged scam in connection with the procurement of books to the Periyar Arivulaga Library in Coimbatore.
The case relates to the alleged procurement of “AI-Generated” books to the public libraries in the State at high prices.
Making submissions before the bench of Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi, Sathyan submitted that a structured FIR would be registered within 4 days. He also assured the court that no person would be spared, especially in a corruption case like the one in present case.
The Madras High Court, on Wednesday (November 11) wondered how the translated version of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's “Mann Ki Baat” (translated into Tamil as Manathin Kural”) was not purchased for public libraries in the State despite recommendation and instead the book, published by Publisher accused in the scam, were found suitable to be purchased.
The bench of Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi was hearing a contempt petition in connection with the alleged scam in procurement of books in public libraries across the State.
“I was told that Prime Minister's Mann Ki Baat was recommended by the expert committee but it was not procured. Manathin Kural was not procured but Agal Vilakku's books, you found worthy to procure?” Justice Swaminathan asked.
Case Title: Anbil Mahesh Poyyamozhi v The State
Case Number: Crl OP 33116 of 2026
The Madras High Court has granted time till November 17 for the State to respond to the petition filed by former Education Minister Anbil Mahesh in connection with an alleged corruption case.
Justice V Lakshminarayanan issued notice to the State and directed it to file a counter by November 17. The court adjourned the hearing at the request of the State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan, assisted by Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani, who informed the court that the remand petition of the 2nd accused (Muthukumar) was being heard by the Special Court today and a detailed counter had to be filed bringing all these facts.
A Special Investigation Team (SIT) appointed by the State to investigate the POCSO case involving granite baron Veeramani has informed the Madras High Court that the first chargesheet has been filed and multiple other chargesheets will also be filed in the coming days.
Making submissions before Justice V Lakshminarayanan, State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan, assisted by Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani, informed the court that a chargesheet had been filed in one of the cases. The court was also informed that in connection with another case, in which multiple victims were involved, the SIT intended to file multiple chargesheets.
The SIT also submitted a status report informing the court of the progress of the investigation. Taking note of the report, the court said that substantial progress was being made and directed the High Court registry to keep the status report in a sealed cover.
Case Title: G Kodeeswaran v The State of Tamil Nadu and Others
Case Number: WP(MD) No 32363 of 2026
The Madras High Court is set to examine whether a person who converts to Christianity can continue to claim reservation as “Most Backward Class”.
The bench of Justice GR Swaminathan and Justice MD Sumathi has issued notice to the Backward Classes, Most Backward Classes and, Minorities Welfare Department, the Human Resources Management Department, the Tamil Nadu Backward Classes Commission, and the Secretary of Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission.
The petitioner pointed out that one of the entries confers Backward Class status on members of the Church of South India (CSI). He submitted that as per this, any individual, including a member belonging to a forward class, can instantly claim Backward Class status merely by acquiring membership in the CSI through baptism.
The court noted that if such an assertion was true, it needed a serious rethink of the government order.
“The Petitioner's counsel startled us by asserting that if a Brahmin gets converted and joins CSI denomination, he can enjoy OBC status as per the present statutory framework. If this assertion is true, then a serious re-think is certainly called for,” the court noted.
The Secretary to Government, Department of Personnel and Training, has informed the Madras High Court that the Central Government has accorded sanction to prosecute two IAS officers in connection with the tender irregularities scam.
When the matter came up for hearing, Justice Anand Venkatesh was informed that the Centre had accorded sanction to prosecute the two officers – KS Kandasamy and K Vijaya Karthikeyan. The court was also informed that the investigating agency would be acting upon the sanction and take steps to conduct an investigation against the officers and file a final report.
Taking note of the sanction, the judge orally remarked that the present case was a classic example of how the criminal law worked in the country where the law moved fast against the poor but needed a push when the case related to influential people.
Former Madras High Court Judge Justice CS Karnan Passes Away
Former judge of the Madras High Court and Calcutta High Court, Justice CS Karnan, has passed away in Chennai on Friday. His funeral will be conducted on Saturday (November 14). He was 71 years old and was undergoing treatment at a private hospital in Chennai.
Justice Karnan, born as Karunanithi, was appointed as a judge of the Madras High Court in 2009. In 2016, he was transferred to the Calcutta High Court.
It may be noted that Justice (Retd) Karnan was the first serving judge to be jailed. A seven-judge bench of the Supreme Court, headed by then Chief Justice of India JS Khehar and observed that Justice Karnan had committed contempt of court, the judiciary and the judicial process and sentenced him to 6 months imprisonment. Though the SC had ordered him to be arrested forthwith, Justice Karnan had evaded arrest for more than a month, after which he was arrested. During this time, Justice Karnan retired from the judicial service.

