Past Criminal Cases Alone Can't Justify Police Surveillance: Telangana High Court Issues Guidelines For Opening, Review Of Rowdy Sheets

  • Past Criminal Cases Alone Cant Justify Police Surveillance: Telangana High Court Issues Guidelines For Opening, Review Of Rowdy Sheets

    Every rowdy sheet must have due regard to individual's personal liberty and privacy, Court said.

    The Telangana High Court issued comprehensive guidelines governing opening, closure of rowdy sheets and police surveillance emphasizing that the object of surveillance is preventive and not punitive and its continued maintenance, in absence of sufficient reasons interferes with personal liberty of a person exposing him to social stigma. The court passed the order while quashing a rowdy...

    The Telangana High Court issued comprehensive guidelines governing opening, closure of rowdy sheets and police surveillance emphasizing that the object of surveillance is preventive and not punitive and its continued maintenance, in absence of sufficient reasons interferes with personal liberty of a person exposing him to social stigma. 

    The court passed the order while quashing a rowdy sheet pending against a city businessman for nearly 18 years, despite his acquittal in all major criminal cases.

    The single judge bench of Justice N. Tukaramji, while allowing the plea, has also issued a comprehensive set of guidelines. The court has said that this must be strictly followed by police authorities regarding the opening, review, and closure of rowdy sheets.

    “The object of surveillance is preventive and not punitive. Its continued maintenance, in the absence of sufficient and contemporaneous justification, would result in unwarranted interference with the personal liberty of the individual and may also expose him to social stigma...The DGP shall issue the necessary circular instructions and communicate the compliance framework to all Commissioners of Police and Superintendents of Police within four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. The jurisdictional authorities shall thereafter undertake a comprehensive review of all existing rowdy sheets and complete the exercise within three months from the date of receipt of the said instructions…”, the court has noted in the order.

    The court issued the following guidelines for police:

    1. Verification of Eligibility: The SHO would be required to independently verify whether an individual falls under Standing Order 601 by the Police. Mere registration of FIRs or isolated criminal cases cannot justify opening a rowdy sheet, the court adds. For context, Standing Order No. 601 of the Telangana State (Andhra Pradesh) Police Manual, mentions the categories of persons who may be classified as rowdies and against whom rowdy sheets may be opened, also based on the habituality of the conduct which is relevant.
    2. Reasoned Proposals: The SHO must submit detailed proposals specifying the applicable category, case outcomes, and material establishing 'habituality' and the necessity for surveillance.
    3. Independent Approval: Senior officers must not mechanically approve SHO recommendations. They must record specific reasons for authorizing the opening of a rowdy sheet, the court says.
    4. Comprehensive Review: Before renewal, the SHO must undertake a fresh assessment, specifically recording if the individual has been an accused in any case in the preceding five years, the date of the last crime, and material indicating if victims are unwilling to complain.
    5. Periodic Review: Renewal proposals must distinguish between the material that led to the original opening of the sheet and subsequent material justifying its continuation. Mere repetition of old cases or general apprehensions will not suffice, the court has stated. Acquittals, discharges, compromises, closure reports and other forms of termination of criminal proceedings shall be duly considered. The period elapsed since the last criminal case or incident, the individual's subsequent conduct, the absence of fresh complaints and any circumstances indicating cessation of the alleged activities shall also be taken into account. Old criminal cases, previous entries or an isolated conviction from the distant past shall not, by themselves, justify continued surveillance. The competent Gazetted Officer shall independently scrutinise the entire renewal proposal and the supporting material and shall not treat the SHO's recommendation as conclusive.
    6. Disposal of Rowdy Sheet Deletion requests: Representations seeking deletion of names from rowdy sheets should be disposed of by a reasoned order, preferably within six weeks of receipt. Any representation seeking deletion of an individual's name from a rowdy sheet shall be objectively examined by the competent authority after verifying the relevant criminal records, outcomes of the proceedings, subsequent conduct and continuing necessity for surveillance
    7. Supervisory scrutiny and discontinuance: The Commissioners of Police and Superintendents of Police concerned shall ensure the implementation of these directions through their supervisory officers and periodically scrutinise the rowdy sheets maintained in their respective jurisdictions, particularly those continued for prolonged periods or in respect of individuals against whom no criminal case has been registered during the preceding five years. Wherever an individual no longer satisfies the requirements of Standing Order No. 601 or sufficient material does not exist to justify continued surveillance, the rowdy sheet shall be discontinued and the consequential surveillance records appropriately updated. Such discontinuance shall not preclude fresh action in accordance with law if subsequent credible material warrants it.

    “…The mere maintenance of a rowdy sheet shall not, by itself, result in repeated summoning or compulsory attendance at a Police Station, restriction of movement, interference with occupation, public humiliation or harassment. Any such action must have independent legal justification and conform to the procedure established by law….”, the court said. 

    It however expressly clarified that the directions are intended to regulate, and not to restrict or curtail, the lawful exercise of preventive police powers.

    To recap, Senior Counsel Bommagani Prabhakar, appearing for the petitioner, had challenged the continued surveillance of his client by the Chatrinaka Police Station before the High Court.

    According to the petitioner, the rowdy sheet was opened against him in 2008 based on an FIR. After this, the name of the petitioner in the said rowdy sheet has been continuing for 18 years without any reason, said the counsel.

    The petitioner also contended that he had been acquitted in multiple cases, and proceedings were stopped under Section 258 [power to stop proceedings in summons case by the Magistrate] of the CrPC in another relevant case. The petitioner told the court further that only one case pertaining to a neighbourhood quarrel in 2010 led to the payment of fine as punishment.

    The petitioner further argued that the continued surveillance, repeated summoning to the police station, and the social stigma attached to such aspects, violated his fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 21. The rowdy sheet against him continued even after repeated representations seeking deletion of his name, the counsel added.

    On the other hand, the State's counsel, Adv. Sridhar Bhuvanagiri, defended the non-deletion of the petitioner's name from the rowdy sheet, stating that the petitioner had a history of seven criminal cases related to offences affecting public peace.

    It also relied on a 2010 conviction against the petitioner under Sections 324, 452, and 504 of the IPC. The state also claimed that the members of the public were reluctant to lodge complaints against him out of fear. Hence, the rowdy sheet was necessary for preventive surveillance, the police added.

    The single judge bench, after perusing the material, noted as below:

    “…The continuation of the rowdy sheet against the petitioner, without relevant and contemporaneous material establishing the necessity for continued surveillance and without reasoned orders upon periodic review in accordance with the applicable Police Standing Orders, is declared arbitrary, disproportionate and violative of the petitioner's fundamental rights under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India…”.

    The court further observed that the Station House Officer's recommendation to continue the rowdy sheet was based on the vague ground that the petitioner was 'active and energetic', whereas the Assistant Commissioner of Police [reviewing authority] endorsed the proposal till 31.12.2026 without due application of mind, in violation of the police standing orders.

    “…Continuation [of rowdy sheet] cannot be justified merely by referring to the circumstances prevailing at the time when the rowdy sheet was originally opened. The object of surveillance is preventive and not punitive. Its continued maintenance, in the absence of sufficient and contemporaneous justification, would result in unwarranted interference with the personal liberty…”, the court clarified further.

    While Standing Order 602(2) by the Telangana State (Andhra Pradesh) Police Manual allows for continuation even without criminal involvement in the preceding five years, the court noted that such action must be supported by a 'considered opinion, on the basis of relevant material', revealing that the individual's activities are prejudicial to public order.

    Relying on the landmark judgment in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India(2017), the court iterated that any state action infringing on privacy must pass the three-fold test of legality, legitimate State interest, and proportionality.

    The court, hence, inferred that the continuation of rowdy sheet against the petitioner is arbitrary and unsustainable.

    Accordingly, the court directed the respondents to remove the petitioner's name from the rowdy sheet.

    Sebin James

    Sebin James is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Telangana High Court

    Next Story